|

Finding
out for sure if a twin is fraternal or identical is called zygosity
determination. It is often important to know what type of twins you have.
It can help in understanding their development, explaining some of their
social behaviors, and, of course, satisfying curiosity. It can also be
important if medical illnesses occur, for such reasons as determining the
heredity of the illness or whether organ transplantation is needed.
There are several methods that determine twin type, or zygosity.
They vary in accuracy and expense. Many times, insurance companies do not
cover the cost of this determination. The methods include:
SIMILARITY METHOD
This is perhaps the most obvious
method and the one used by the common person. If they look alike, they are
identical or monozygotic; if they look different, they are fraternal or
dizygotic. Experienced observers can be quite accurate in labeling the
twin type using things such as hair; eyes; skin color; shapes of nose,
lips, and eyes; fingerprint analysis; and tissue grafts between twins.
These experienced observers, usually researchers, can claim a 94-96
percent chance of correctly identifying the twin type, compared to blood
tests.
PLACENTA METHOD
Analyzing the placenta(s) has
been the common way that obstetricians have determined twin type in the
past, and placental analysis is still performed today. Unfortunately, this
method can be quite inaccurate and depends on the expertise of the doctor.
In the past it was assumed that one placenta meant that the twins were
monozygotic, or identical, and that two placentas meant that they were
dizygotic, or fraternal. This has proved to be untrue. Parents can often
be misled when given the twin type based only on examination of the fetal
tissues by an inexperienced clinician.
More important than the
placenta itself are the fetal membranes, which can be helpful in
determining twin type. They are the thin membranes filled with fluid that
surround the fetus and are attached to the placenta. The amnion is the
inner membrane, and the chorion is the outer membrane. A shared amnion
always means monozygotic twins, but is very rare. Two amnions and one
chorion also means monozygotic twins. If there are two amnions and two
chorions the twin type can be either mono- or dizygotic.
Fraternal
or dizygotic twins will always have two placentas, as the two eggs implant
separately into the uterus. However, if the eggs implant close together
the placentas can become fused and take on the appearance of one placenta.
Twins can then be mislabeled monozygotic.
However, identical twins
do not always have one placenta. Monozygotic twins come from an egg that
splits into two. The timing of the split will determine the number of
placentas. If the split happens after the egg has already implanted into
the uterus, there will be one placenta. If the split happens earlier,
before implantation, then the two eggs can implant separately into the
uterus and form two separate placentas. The twins will still be identical.
BLOOD TESTING
Using blood tests can give an accurate
determination of twin type. There are many other blood groups besides the
usual ABO blood type. There are also serum proteins and enzymes. The more
blood groups studied, the more accurate the identification will be. Using
eight blood groups, there is a 97 percent chance of correctly identifying
identical twins. With the use of more blood groups, the accuracy can climb
to nearly 99 percent. HLA typing is a similar measure of many blood
proteins and can be 100 percent accurate. This is the type of testing that
is done for matching donors for organ transplants. It must be performed in
a specialized laboratory. Blood typing tends to be much less expensive
than HLA typing.
DNA
TESTING
This
is called DNA
fingerprinting. This method of twin typing is virtually 100 percent
accurate and is performed only at specialized laboratories.
DNA
contains the genetic building blocks of an organism. In
DNA
fingerprinting, the DNA is
separated into smaller segments and compared. The chance of two
individuals having the same DNA
sequence at the same time would be extremely rare unless they were
monozygotic twins. The test can be performed from blood specimens or from
scrapings of cells from the inner cheek, called a buccal smear. This
method, while being one of the most accurate, is also the most expensive.
Original text: http://www.nomotc.org/library/twinning_facts.html
|